Skip to content

Keeping Dental Problems Out of the Emergency Room

February 29, 2012

If you’re suffering from a throbbing toothache, the hospital emergency room is not a good choice for treatment. The wait time could be hours, there’s rarely a dentist on staff, and procedures like tooth extractions cost far more if they take place in a hospital versus being performed in a dentist’s office. Yet increasingly, for people covered under Medicaid or for those without any dental insurance, the emergency room is the only option when serious dental problems arise.

A new report by the Pew Center on the States finds that preventable dental conditions were responsible for more than 830,000 visits to the emergency room last year; a 16% increase since 2006. Because ER’s aren’t set up to treat non-accident related dental problems, most of these patients received only symptomatic treatment like pain medication or antibiotics. Some 80% were referred to a dentist for follow-up visits. And so the cycle continues.

Why the rise in emergency visits for preventable dental problems? According to the Pew study, “A major driver…is a failure by states to ensure that disadvantaged people have access to routine preventive care from dentists and other providers.” The report estimates that some 47 million Americans live in areas that the federal government identifies as experiencing a serious shortage of dentists. This is especially true in rural areas where people live very far from the nearest dentist. But the dearth of dental providers is only part of the problem. There are also far too few providers who will agree to see Medicaid patients—in 2008 for example, fewer than half of the dentists in 25 states treated any Medicaid patients. For children the situation is particularly dire; the Pew study finds that in 2009, “more than 16 million Medicaid enrolled children (56 percent) received no dental care—not even a routine exam.” Access problems are the most likely explanation because federal law mandates state Medicaid coverage for all children’s preventive dental services.

A shortage of community dentists; a lack of providers who accept Medicaid patients; a growing number of Americans who have no dental insurance—all these factors result in a reliance on expensive emergency care for acute problems that could have been prevented by regular office visits and simple wellness routines. Sound familiar? These issues mirror the problems of cost and access that plague the rest of the health care system; especially when it comes to controlling chronic illnesses like diabetes and heart disease and preventing unnecessary ER visits and hospital admissions.

As health reform rolls out, some 30 million more Americans will have health insurance and will be eligible for preventive care and services without co-pays or deductibles. To help meet the expected growth in demand for primary care services the Affordable Care Act includes several provisions meant to minimize provider shortages—especially in underserved areas. This includes raising Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement rates for primary care visits to encourage providers to accept patients covered by these government plans. Medical education incentives include loan forgiveness programs for future primary care providers who promise to work in rural or other underserved areas. Finally, the ACA also directs funding toward educating and training more nurse practitioners and physician assistants to help fill the workforce gap.

These kinds of initiatives are equally important to improve access to dental care.

The Affordable Care Act mandates that all insurance plans include an oral health benefit for children up to the age of 21 for “basic and essential services.” Tooth decay is the most common chronic illness in children and poverty is directly linked to the severity of the problem. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services found that nearly 80 percent of the decayed teeth of poor two to five year olds and 40-50 percent of the decayed permanent and primary teeth in 6-14 year olds were unfilled (untreated). Left untreated, tooth decay leads to pain, infection, loss of teeth and systemic illnesses that can even result in death.

The ACA is devoting more funding to dental education—particularly for students who intend on practicing in community clinics and underserved areas. Also, a new commission is charged with coming up with “more equitable” reimbursement for dentists who see Medicaid or CHIP patients. Currently, a handful of states have reimbursement rates that are similar to those provided by  private insurers; in others payments can amount to only a third or less of customary charges.

But even with these changes a shortage of dental practitioners will still prevent the American Dental Association from achieving its goal “to get better dental care to the millions of Americans who don’t receive it.” According to Health Reform GPS (a joint project of George Washington University and Robert Wood Johnson Foundation) as of September 2009, “there were 4,230 dental health professions shortage areas, within which more than 42 million people live. The U.S. Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) estimates that it would take an increase of more than 9,500 dental professionals in order to reduce the ratio in shortage areas to 1 dental professional for every 3,000 individuals.”

The answer is to shift some of primary dental care to a new class of professionals; so-called “dental therapists” who, according to a report by Martha Bebinger on WBUR, “are paid about half of what dentists make. They have roughly two years more training than hygienists but two years less than a dentist.” Dental equivalents of nurse practitioners, dental therapists could perform standard dental procedures like check-ups and cleaning as well as filling cavities, pulling teeth or applying sealants. They are already licensed in more than 50 countries, including in Canada, Britain, Australia, and New Zealand where they have been safely practicing for more than 30 years.

State dental societies, (not surprisingly) generally oppose licensing dental therapists or advanced-practice dental hygienists. Minnesota and Alaska are the only two states to have passed laws allowing dental therapists to practice—and that was only after overcoming strong opposition from dentists and setting limitations on where they can treat patients. For example, in Minnesota, Bebinger reports that “dental therapists can only practice in offices where at least 50 percent of the patients are low-income.” In Alaska, dental therapists have been providing preventive and basic dental care to 35,000 children and families in remote Alaska Native villages since 2005. A two-year evaluation by RTI International found that “Dental therapists in Alaska are performing well and operating safely within their scope of work,” according to Scott Wetterhall, RTI’s principal investigator and lead author of the report.

Paul Levy, the former hospital CEO who publishes the Not Running A Hospital blog blasted the state dental societies “who oppose the licensing of dental assistants who would carry out low-level dental procedures.”  He points to a quote in the WBUR piece from Dr. Charles Silvius, president of the Massachusetts Dental Society who doesn’t believe dental therapists are the answer to solving the access problem:

“We’re almost setting up a two-tier system of care,” [Silvius] warns. “People who are geographically located near a dentist or have the ability to pay for it will be treated by dentists. And those who are more remote or possibly don’t have health care coverage are going to be treated by non-dentists, and I don’t think that’s moral or ethical.”

Levy dismisses this concern as being less than forthright; “So, we dentists are not going to provide care to certain populations in the state.  But, we’ll certainly oppose anybody else doing it.  How moral and ethical is that?” he asks.

It’s more likely that dentists see dental therapists as posing a threat to their livelihood. Sarah Wovcha, executive director at Children’s Dental Services in Minneapolis told Bebinger that by using dental therapists community clinics can double the amount of dental care they provide at half the price. “This initiative is really the best that I’ve seen in health care reform,” Wovcha tells WBUR, “It’s cost-effective, it’s high quality, it’s taking dental hygienists and bringing them to a different level where they can fill a gap in a need for care.”

In the end, the Pew report about the increase in emergency room dental visits brings a needed news hook to a long-brewing problem. Dental health is important—and not just for children. Besides the pain, infection, lost school or work days, tooth decay can lead to tooth loss and disfigurement. Poor dental health is associated with poverty and it goes both ways; if you are poor it’s difficult to access dental care, and if you are missing teeth, it’s difficult to get a decent job.

Health reform mandates dental coverage for children but not for adults. That seems very short-sighted if the other option is taxpayer-funded emergency room care. The ACA provides some modest funding for education programs to encourage dentists to practice in underserved areas. But there needs to be more. For starters, state dental societies need to drop their opposition to licensing dental therapists who can greatly expand access to affordable care to those who need it most.

 

11 Comments
  1. It seems to go back to the question of what a profession is supposed to satisfy and why was it originally set up. Is it supposed to satisfy a social need in a predictable and timely manner, or is it supposed to satisfy the needs of a guild to make more income and get more prestige by controlling supply and demand?

  2. We are in need of more community dental clinics across our nation. Corporate ADA has power and money to change the current dental care delivery system for the better if Americans would speak out against the American Dental Associations deceiving and pacifying public relations campaign for a better public image.

    The American Dental Association’s lack of leadership, mismanagement, and decades of irreversible trends, some being history while others continue today; is the leading factor for unmet dental needs in our nation. These trends and policies include racial and gender discrimination, unnecessary extractions and placement of dentures as a treatment plan, mandated and excessive use of fluoride, the use of mercury in restorations and ADA policies which prevent Americans from receiving oral healthcare by suppressing qualified competitors that provide oral health services to those with disparities.

    The American Dental Association works against its own vision and mission statement by suppressing competition that has been trained and educated in providing oral health care services to those that are unable to pay the high prices charged by dentist, leaving Americans without needed dental care.

    The American Dental Association’s waste of time and money, spent on lobbying and ADA’s strong arm tactics against competitors such as denturists, dental health aide therapists, and independent practices of dental hygienists needs to change for better production in meeting the oral health needs of Americans.

    This wasted money could be used in further educating the professions ADA fights against in alleviating ADA’s bogus public safety concerns. Corporate ADA could take portions of the millions of dollars it uses for lobbying and fighting against its competitors and instead, send each state, grants to compensate dentists who except Medicaid recipients. The American Dental Association could provide grants for dental programs in community healthcare centers across America. This would greatly improve our Nations oral healthcare concerns and unmet dental needs.

    Gary W. Vollan L.D.
    State Coordinator, Wyoming State Denturist Association
    http://www.wysda.org

    http://www.opensecrets.org/pacs/lookup2.php?strID=C00000729

  3. I must say, you have done some great research about the topic ! and along with that a nicely compiled and written content ! …enjoyed going through it ! =) thanks alot !

  4. Women with hormone-receptor positive early dentist cancer prescribed letrozole for five years after surgery are also
    20% less likely to recall receiving dentistfeeding advice from
    their physicians compared to higher educated women.
    In July 2012, the Jonsson center is dedicated to promoting research and translating basic
    science into leading-edge clinical studies.
    Oh God no, don’t say that, she says proudly.

  5. My brother suggested I migfht like thhis blog.
    He was otally right. This publish truly made my day.You cann not imagine simply how much time I had spent for this information!
    Thabk you!

  6. CEL permalink

    The problem is I have dental and medical insurance and neither covered the er visit. I had terrible pain in my ear, neck, and cheek starting on friday night. By the next evening I couldn’t do anything. I hadn’t slept nor eaten because the pain was so bad. At the time I didn’t know it was a tooth causing the problem, all I knew was I was in severe pain. After going to the er on sunday and getting some pain relief meds i was billed for all of it. Neither insurance plan covered er dental visits. How was I supposed to know it was going to be a tooth causing this pain. I thought it was my ear the whole time. So i pay my high premiums for good medical and dental insurance and here i am, stuck with the bills, paying for them myself. Thanks Anthem. Keep up the great work.

  7. This is very helpful in getting information regarding dental problems and their aftereffects and also the reasons for the problem
    It is very nice to know about the dental treatments and their benefits

  8. Really a good post to read if a person is suffering from throbbing toothache, the hospital emergency room is not a good choice for treatment A shortage of community dentists; a lack of providers who accept Medicaid patients; a growing number of Americans who have no dental insurance—all these factors result in a reliance on expensive emergency care for acute problems that could have been prevented by regular office visits and simple wellness routine.
    http://www.wellness.com/dir/1455338/dentist/ak/anchor-point/charles-r-cordova-dds

  9. Great post. Its good to know that we always have the best dentists in town. However, inevitable things happen. These are useful information that would prevent anyone from going to an emergency room just because of a simple toothache. Thanks for the information.

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Keeping Dental Problems Out of the Emergency Room « Denturist, Denturism and Denturitry
  2. Dental webs » Cheap Dental Insurance Washington

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 328 other followers

%d bloggers like this: