Skip to content

Obesity: Fact vs. Fiction

February 28, 2012

By Maggie Mahar

Dr. Nortin Hadler, author of Worried Sick and Stabbed in the Back, is well-known for debunking medical myths. But in his latest book, Rethinking Aging (UNC Press), Hadler, a professor at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, commits what some might call medical heresy, suggesting that, perhaps, as we approach middle-age, “It’s OK to be Overweight.”

Wait a minute. What is Hadler saying? Everyone knows that obese Americans are driving our health care bills to the moon. Some argue that they should pay higher insurance premiums. Meanwhile, those extra pounds are sending millions to an early grave. And we all know that if our obese neighbors would just put down their forks and get on a treadmill, the pounds would melt away.

But as is so often the case, what “everyone knows” just isn’t true.

Myth #1: The U.S. spends so much on health care in large part because too many of us are just plain fat.

Here, the conventional wisdom ignores a compelling 2007 McKinsey & Co. study which demonstrates that obesity does not begin to explain why, in 2005, we shelled out $480 billion more for health care than peer nations.

Make no mistake, obesity is expensive, and linked to a host of diseases–especially later onset diabetes.

But when McKinsey’s expert number-crunchers compared the prevalence and cost of 130 diseases (including obesity, heart disease and diabetes) in the U.S. and six other countries (Japan, Germany, France, Italy, Spain and the UK), they discovered that the U.S. spent under $25 billion treating all 130 conditions—a fraction of the “extra” $480 billion that we spent on health care.

Where did the other $455 billion go? First, we pay more for everything, from doctors’ services to medical devices. McKinsey’s analysts calculated that higher prices account for roughly $280 billion in “additional spending.” Secondly, “inefficiencies and complexities” in our health care system add another $150 billion to the tab. “Fee-for service” encourages doctors to see more patients. Finally, administration, regulation and the many go-betweens (brokers and agents) needed to deliver care in our fragmented system cost nearly $100 billion.” None of this is news.

Why, then, do we continue to blame the obese? The Incidental Economist’s Aaron Carroll explains: “when confronted with the numbers, people feel a need to find a reason. They need something to blame.  And no one ever wants to blame the system.”  In a culture that equates overweight with gluttony and sloth, it’s easier to blame the victim.

Myth #2   If they would just “eat less” and “move more” the problem would be solved.

If only it were that simple.  But as physicians who treat obese patients reveal in an eye-opening PBS documentary titled “Fat,” even when compliant patients diet and exercise under a doctor’s supervision, 95 percent regain whatever weight they lose.

The merely overweight can, in fact, lose fifteen pounds, and keep it off—if they do it very slowly, and focus on eating smaller portions.  (Those who buy into some of the quicker solutions offered by our $40 billion weight-loss industry are likely to find themselves shedding, and re-acquiring, the same 15 pounds, over and over again.)

The truly obese face a far more difficult problem. Obesity is an extraordinarily complicated disease caused by a combination of bio-chemical forces, genetics, and environment. Many physicians who don’t specialize in this area “still believe that obesity is caused by eating too much and not exercising enough, but such thinking is too simplistic,” says Dr Robert Lustig, an obesity expert at the University of California, San Francisco. “If it were that simple we would have solved it a long time ago,” adds Dr. Lee Kaplan, head of the Weight Reduction Program at Mass General.  “More than 400 genes are involved in weight regulation.”

No wonder some physicians tell obese patients to forget the diets and focus on exercise. Swim. Join a dance class. Their silhouettes won’t change, but they’ll be healthier.

Myth # 3 Fat Kills

Not necessarily true, says Hadler, pointing to two 2010 studies published in Obesity  and the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society which suggest that only the “morbidly obese” (with a body-mass index over 35)  and the “abnormally thin” (BMI under 18.5) “incur any increased risk of death before their time.” (A standard measure of heft, BMI considers both weight and height).  “Obese” subjects (BMI of 30-35) died no sooner than “normal folks.” Those who were “overweight” (BMI of 25-30) actually lived longer. Padding offers some protection, particularly for the elderly.  As for the underweight, apparently you can be too thin.

“In the past, we were fooled by studies that didn’t adjust for socioeconomic status,” Hadler explains. Many of the poor are obese, and they do die sooner than the rest of us. But obesity is not the major factor behind their premature deaths. What kills them is a combination of factors, with stress and tobacco at the top of the list.

Ultimately, studies reveal that fitness is more important than fat. Of course our highly profitable weight-loss industry does not want us to hear this.No one makes much money when you swim or jog.

As for Hadler, he recommends exercise for aging Americans, not because it will prolong your life (he’s skeptical), but because you will enjoy life more: “Try playing with a toddler,” writes Hadler, a grandfather who doesn’t weigh himself (he admits he’s probably overweight), but rides his bicycle over hill and dale 100 miles a week.

Maggie Mahar is a notable health care policy blogger as well as the former Health Fellow at The Century Foundation where she was editor of HealthBeat. She is the author of  “Money-Driven Medicine: The Real Reason Health Care Costs So Much” (Harper Collins 2006)


From → Health care

  1. Yo, Maggie! Great to see you up and running again…

    And thanks for this. As you know I’m just a layman but coming up on ten years now in my post-retirement work with seniors I can assure anyone that there are plenty of fat old people. I have also heard at least two physicians mention that when someone has to spend time in a hospital those with a little extra weight may have an advantage, pretty much for the same reason that fat people live longer without food — calories in the bank. Morbidly obese people, of course, are not in this category.

    (The one effect of aging that seems to be most widespread, aside from wrinkling skin and muscle atrophy, is mobility. Even most who remain ambulatory without canes or walkers lose that quickness of step they may have had in their Fifties and Sixties.)

    Changing subjects, last night’s ABC News had a report that people who use sleeping pills have an increased rate of dying from all causes compared with those who do not. The speculation is that insomnia is often a symptom of more serious conditions — they mentioned heart disease, diabetes, asthma and even cancer when hormones change — life-threatening when insomnia is not investigated.

  2. lhf permalink

    Winston Churchill should be Hadler’s primary example!

    I think we should be looking at the cost of drugs to understand where the money is going. Some of the numbers in Rethinking Aging are astonishing. Mostly for drugs that have no effect or even detrimental effect.

    I’ve watched as my friends add drug after drug to combat high blood pressure (usually eventually 3 drugs with very little result), high cholesterol, gout, and various heart malfunctions such as atrial fibrillation. Endless sorting goes on while the medical people try to balance the adverse effects of combining these drugs and then, of course, adding more drugs to counter the various side effects that can’t be sorted out.

    Overdiagnosis and overtreatment are huge money sinks and the drug companies are complicit – along with the media and their “scare of the week” as Hadler describes it. On the other hand, alot of old people go to the doctor to get attention – sad but true – and this runs up the bill under the fee for service model.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: