Skip to content

Politics Be Damned: “5 Trends That Will Shape U.S. Health Care”

November 6, 2012

With election day upon us at last, we are all being deluged with projections as to who will be sitting in the White House come January. I have been watching this process from an emotional distance for at least the last month or so as the media reports the daily ups and downs of approval ratings, possible electoral vote scenarios and political reactions to the monster hurricane that just devastated parts of my city.

For a campaign in which candidates spent a total of $3 billion, the stakes are high for more than just individual issues like Medicare, unemployment, taxes, abortion and all the other hot button items that divide our country. If elected, Mitt Romney and the conservative base of the Republican party stand to fundamentally change the nature of this nation; sacrificing social programs, tolerance and federal responsibility to create a pro-big business, free-market country that cedes important federal powers to self-interested state authorities.

Of course we know how Gov. Romney and his erstwhile supporters in Congress feel about the health reform law. A long-time promise of the campaign has been to immediately repeal Obamacare, legislation Romney calls a “bad law.” He’s said that he plans to immediately grant waivers to all states, allowing them to ignore the law and stop work on setting up mandated health insurance exchanges. The next step is to use Congress’s  budget reconciliation process to repeal nearly all elements of the health law over the next several months.

There are  serious doubts, even among detractors of the ACA, that a Romney administration could successfully grant the state waivers and cut off funding for the health law. Federal courts are sure to get involved and block these widespread actions. Don’t forget that some popular aspects of the ACA–allowing young adults to stay on their parent’s health plans and requiring insurers to accept people with pre-existing conditions, for example–are already in place. It will be very difficult or impossible to use budget reconciliation to repeal these provisions, especially without an alternative plan in place.

That said, I believe there are key aspects of health reform that will continue to advance whatever the outcome of the election. These are the fundamental changes in how care is payed for and delivered that are already transforming our health care system. Several months ago, I was asked by Columbia University’s Mailman School of Public Health to write an article for a new magazine they were publishing. There have been many changes in Columbia’s  public health program and the resulting magazine conveys the breadth of  work done by researchers associated with the school and emphasizes a new “life course” approach to education that considers the influence of public health on every age and stage of life.

My assignment was to predict which aspects of health reform would prevail  if 1) the Supreme Court ruled that the ACA was unconstitutional, or the individual mandate was unconstitutional (it didn’t) or 2) Obama lost the election (as of today, still don’t know.). After many months and changing predictions, I agree with Michael S. Sparer, chair of Mailman School’s Department of Health Policy and Management who told me;

“There are important trends reshaping the healthcare system that will continue regardless of who wins the presidential election, who controls the next Congress, and whether the ACA survives or is repealed.” He continues in the article, “Indeed, while the ACA supports and encourages many of these trends, there simply is no going back. A healthcare revolution is under way.”

The five trends I chose to highlight include:

1) “Farewell Fee For Service, Hello Accountable Care”

2) “Playing Up Prevention”

3) “Rewarding Quality, Punishing Carelessness”

4) “Evidence Is the Best Medicine”

5) “Expanding the Reach of Medicaid”

I do point out that despite widespread adoption of innovative payment and delivery models  by Medicare and also by commercial insurers, there are serious barriers to reaching universal coverage without the ACA. It is vital that Medicare not be turned into a stingy voucher system, Medicaid be expanded and not made into a block grant program, and that all Americans be offered the chance to have affordable, high quality health coverage. It would be heartbreaking to come this far for naught.

Fingers crossed for tonight’s results; we still have a long way to go.

You can read “5 Trends That Will Shape U.S. Health Care (No Matter How the Politics Play Out” here in Columbia Public Health, and perhaps come up with your own predictions for the future of health care.



From → Uncategorized

  1. Naomi, your article is outstanding. Unfortunately my poor old eyes had a hard time reading it online and didn’t fare much better when I printed it.
    You deserve to have your work posted where it can be accessed and easily read (and copied for quotations) by as many readers as possible
    I know there are copyright considerations and all that, but this particular article is too timely and well-done to let stuff like that make it hard to access. The ACO illustration using a patient with MS is powerful stuff. There’s lots more but I’m writing from memory, and frankly I had to scan part of it because the print was so small.
    But I’m still an avid fan.

    • Thank you John for your kind comments. Sorry that the text is hard to read but I should get a few hard copies of the magazine in coming weeks and can make a PDF of the article to send out.

  2. If you are not bound by some commitment to that source perhaps you could cross-publish at The Health Care Blog or Kevin MD. Better yet, right here at your own blog would be a good place as well. You obviously put a lot of work into what you do. You deserve more exposure.

  3. Bob Hertz permalink

    Great article! I have a piece that I would like to send you for your consideration and review.

    Can you give me an email address to which I can send the piece?

    The Health Care Crusade

    • Jose A Jarimba permalink

      Hello Robert, my name is Jose A. Jarimba. I just found Naomi’s site and I also found you. I would like to tell you more about my work, in these coming days. If you don’t mind, send me an e-mail and I would be happy to communicate with you. I am very interested in exchanging information about Health with any one. Here is my e-mail address: My number is: (956)502-9668, just in case! Thanks

  4. Jose A Jarimba permalink

    Hello Naomi, this is my first time reading your material. You do an outstanding job in exposing the over treatment, which you are right about. I am an Author and an Independent Researcher, I discovered the origin of pain, and have successfully found a solution for it. I wrote and published (2/2/2012) a book titled: “The Human Mold prevention from origin”. Our Health complications starts in the womb of our mothers. I am going to write more about my work every day if possible. Please, have your readers ready to learn about their own Health. Sincerely. Jose A Jarimba, Independent Researcher and Adviser, on Human Physical Pain Prevention, Author, Inventor and Symmetrologist.

  5. Thanks for the awesome post

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: